First, let me make it clear that I’m no Imelda.
I’m not even a distant second.
But I do have plenty of shoes—athletic shoes in various colors, waterproof pairs because the weather in Washington State is mostly NOT dry and sunny, winter boots, loafers, two or three pairs of sandals, black and brown low heels, and a pair of higher heels covered in sequins. (I’m pretty sure I bought those at a thrift store for a costume party and wore them just once, but the question is: Why do I keep them around?)
I tell myself I have my “addiction” under control. I no longer need the “fix” of shoe shopping at least once a month and the “high” of shoe buying in spring and fall. At least, I don’t need it the way I did in my 20s and 30s.
Compared to the cravings of many of my friends, my addiction was mild. Yes, shoe-buying accounted for too much of my budget, but I didn’t go into debt. Instead I compensated by bringing a lunch to work and turning down the heat at home. (The lower temperature also provided a reason to wear those knee-high boots on into the spring.)
I wish I could tell a dramatic story about friends holding an intervention and forcing me to join a support group to curb my shoe craving.
But what happened was:
I got older
And wiser
And less willing to sacrifice and suffer for fashion
And in touch with what the impulse shoes of my youth were all about
Getting older meant I had to “pay” for the way I’d treated my feet. I developed tendon issues that require custom-made metal and plastic insoles. They feel as if I’m standing on a lead pipe and they don’t work with heels or most sandals.
- Getting wiser meant I took stock of the shoe space in my closet (about 6 square feet or enough to hold one rack for nine shoes with a little space on the side) and the spare cash in the budget. I realized I was less willing to scrimp on groceries and heat, to sacrifice for fashion.
Getting to the next stage—being less willing to suffer—allowed me to toss out shoes that looked more like stilts, those that didn’t quite fit but were okay as long as standing and walking weren’t required, the ones that needed special cleaning or polishing, and any that went with outfits long departed.
And getting in touch with the symbolism of shoes meant I understood that, no matter what happened to that that chick with the glass slipper, odds were that would never happen to me. Shoes wouldn’t change my life. The majorette boots I got for my birthdays when I was five, six, and seven, never gave me any musical talent. I can’t even clap on the beat. The spiky heels I wore during the disco era (or is that the error?) never made me a decent dancer. The hiking boots I bought never caused me to tackle challenging ascents or lengthy treks.
Beyond that, I realized that the shoes I found seductive—the shoes I HAD to have—weren’t necessarily good for me. In fact, those shoes were often metaphors for the romantic relationships I wandered into while wearing them.
My love affairs with those shoes and those men were often painful, but they made me stronger, and gave me more insight into the workings of the heart andmind—my own and those of others, including my fictional characters.
I’m not saying I no longer gaze into display windows, detour through the shoe sections of department stores, or notice what my friends are wearing. I’m not saying that I don’t sometimes conjure up images of those navy blue sandals or black suede boots I once owned.
But there’s no magic pill, no quick cure for the shoe flu. I expect I’ll have relapses as long as I’m able to get my shoes on without assistance—and maybe even after that.
How about you?
Did you have a love affair with shoes? Are you still involved? Or have you broken it off? If so, how did you do it?
Stop by and tell us about your experiences and you could win a copy of my suspense novel, Sea of Regret. The sequel to An Uncertain Refuge, it’s set at a wildlife rehabilitation center on the Oregon Coast—a site a ruthless developer will stop at nothing to acquire. The protagonist, Kate Dalton, wears sneakers and sandals and flip-flops.
Carolyn J. Rose is the author of several novels, including Hemlock Lake, Through a Yellow Wood, An Uncertain Refuge, A Place of Forgetting, and No Substitute for Murder. She penned two humorous cozy mysteries, The Big Grabowski and Sometimes a Great Commotion, with her husband, Mike Nettleton.
She grew up in New York’s Catskill Mountains, graduated from the University of Arizona, logged two years in Arkansas with Volunteers in Service to America, and spent 25 years as a television news researcher, writer, producer, and assignment editor in Arkansas, New Mexico, Oregon, and Washington. She founded the Vancouver Writers’ Mixers and is an active supporter of her local bookstore, Cover to Cover. Her interests are reading, gardening, and not cooking.
Visit Carolyn’s website www.deadlyduomysteries.com
“Sea of Regret” on Amazon












25 comments
Comments feed for this article
November 26, 2012 at 7:22 am
robitille
Oh, I have an interesting relationship with shoes. I’m a big girl. The only people who have ever called me petite are smarmy, sarcastic sonnuva… Um. Well, let’s just say that 6′ tall isn’t little and it doesn’t come with little feet either. Trying to *find* size 11 & 1/2 EEEEE – no, that’s not a scream, that’s five Es, though you try finding them and you *might* scream – or 12 EEE in something that isn’t Completely Ugly is enough of a challenge. Trying to find “cute shoes” is a lifelong obsession. I think the only reason I haven’t broken the bank on shoes is that I can’t find the dang things in my size anywhere nearby. On the other hand, I have recently discovered that I can shop transvestite shoe shops online. Hey, don’t be like that! These folks love cute shoes and they don’t put up with *uncomfortable* cute shoes, so it’s a good thing all around!
November 26, 2012 at 9:45 am
Carolyn J. Rose
What I like best about blogging is learning something from the comments. I always wondered where performers found those beautiful shoes in larger sizes, and now I know.
November 26, 2012 at 9:08 am
Judith Mehl
What a great blog on shoes! Loved it. My own love affair with shoes was short-lived in my own life because of similar reasons to yours, but I carried it on in my mystery novels. My main character, Kat, loves her shoes, loves buying them on sale, switches them often but still manages to be wearing her running shoes when she needs them–most of the time. My books (the second one, “Game, Set, Murder,” was just released Friday on Amazon and through my website).
Your blog gave me another perspective and I enjoyed it very much. Thank you.
November 26, 2012 at 10:17 am
Carolyn J. Rose
Thanks for stopping by and sharing. I wish you and your books much success.
November 26, 2012 at 9:24 am
christytilleryfrench
Enjoyed the blog, Carolyn. I’m tall – 5’9″ – but blessed with small feet (6) so have no problem finding cute shoes. But I prefer flats and shoes that are comfortable,meaning no lengthy heels. However, the most comfortable shoes I’ve ever worn are cowboy (or would it be cowgirl?) boots.
November 26, 2012 at 9:46 am
Carolyn J. Rose
I had a pair of Acme boots that I wore for a decade. They rocked.
November 26, 2012 at 10:18 am
Nikki Andrews
Great blog, Carolyn. In a short space you managed to give me some hints about the mysterious allure of shoes, which I’ve never understood. My feet hurt if I even look at pointy-toed high heels. But then I’m hard to fit–wide at the toe, narrow at the heel, and long. Toss in bunions (genetic, I’m afraid) and hammer toes (also genetic), and I’m left with running shoes and slippers. Or hiking boots, which are wonderfully comfortable but not exactly appropriate for weddings. Good thing I was never a girly girl.
But, oh, transvestite shoestores online! Great idea!
November 26, 2012 at 10:56 am
morganmandel
I have too many shoes also that I’ll never wear, but last year I did get three grocery bags of shoes together for GoodWill. These were shoes buried in the closet. I hadn’t seen them in years and they didn’t fit anymore, maybe never did!
Still have plenty to spare!
November 26, 2012 at 11:05 am
Carolyn J. Rose
Morgan, good for you for letting go. Yesterday I remembered a “secret stash” in the guest room closet and put a pair (worn just once – what was I thinking?) in a sack destined for a women’s shelter. Hopefully today I can let go of another pair today. Why is this so difficult?
November 26, 2012 at 11:29 am
Wendy Dingwall
Thanks for the cute article! A severly sprained ankle after moving to the mountains of NC cured my addiction. Though I still have the spike heels in the closet on the off chance I ever return to level ground.
November 26, 2012 at 1:22 pm
Carolyn J. Rose
Wendy, I feel your pain. I once fell off a pair of platform shoes on level ground while standing still.
November 26, 2012 at 4:18 pm
Wendy Dingwall
LOL!
November 26, 2012 at 11:39 am
Elizabeth
Shoe stories, like hair stories, probably can tell you everything you’d ever need to know about a person. Why do the shrinks bother with formal tests? Just ask about shoes! As a 6-footer female growing up in 1960s’ Phoenix and a 5’4” world, there was ONE shoe store in the entire metropolis that carried size 12 women’s shoes, with usually about 3 pair to choose from.
My most agonizing moment with shoes came at the first and only 7th-8th grade dance. This was the award we girls had all waited for in 6th grade. Some teacher thought of a “great” mixer to peel the boys off of one wall of the cafeteria become dance floor and the girls off the other wall. We girls were told to put one of our shoes in a heap in the middle of the room. The boys were instructed to select one shoe and match it to the girl and then dance with her. Were we even numbers? I doubt it.
My long pointy-toed flat resembled a canoe. It was the only shoe left on the floor after the boys did the picking through. The dance could not start until somebody retrieved it. That was the longest solo walk of my life. I spent the rest of the dance hiding in the girl’s bathroom and never went to a school dance again. If the adult me could go back in time to that event, I would pick up that canoe, walk over to the teacher who had the great idea, and whack the holy out of him-her. Sorry teachers.
November 26, 2012 at 6:38 pm
Carolyn J. Rose
Great comment. It made me tear up and then laugh and then remember some of the agonizing events from those years.
November 26, 2012 at 1:51 pm
Karen Gilb
Can’t say I ever had a passionate affair with shoes in general. But I did have a pair of red and blue suede ankle boots many years ago that I was madly in love with. Loved them so much, I hung onto them way beyond their “wear” date.
November 26, 2012 at 5:01 pm
Sarah Scott
I’ve been wary of heels since the Easter I wore my first pair with a heel probably no higher than 1-1/2 inches. Still, they left me teetering and sent me shooting feet-first down a fight of stairs that morning at church. Worse, I grabbed a friend’s hand and took her with me…right in front of the cute guy she was trying to impress. Took a few decades to live that down.
November 26, 2012 at 7:07 pm
Mike Nettleton
Carolyn, by the way, has lovely feet. I prefer them naked, but that’s probably more information that you needed, right? My only relationship with shoes centers around hearing Carolyn’s voice just before a social engagement. “You’re not wearing those with that, are you?” That’s the moment I realize I need to dig into the closet for a different pair.
November 26, 2012 at 7:48 pm
Carolyn J. Rose
Lovely feet? Someone is angling to get out of the vacuuming this week.
November 27, 2012 at 1:44 am
Carol Doane (@TheClassicCarol)
I ended my love affair with shoes when I wore two different pair to work and no one noticed. (Not even me).
November 27, 2012 at 11:10 am
Elizabeth
Carol–had to laugh over wearing two different shoes. You’re not the only one–I was sitting, feeling superior and cocky, at a Graduate Record exam having finished the section ahead of everybody else in the test room. Then I looked down. Yup, a different shoe on each foot. Why am I hearing Suzie Orman’s voice saying “DENIED!”
November 27, 2012 at 8:15 am
laurelrainsnow
Loved your post, Carolyn! While my addiction was more for gorgeous handbags, I can totally relate to the “need,” as well as what has to happen in order to let the addiction go.
As for shoes, though, I did have a compulsion to buy high heels and those platforms that were around in the seventies. And I didn’t stop buying them until one day when I fell off my platforms and bruised myself pretty badly…not only my body, but my ego. People saw me fall! Totally embarrassing.
BTW, I loved An Uncertain Refuge, so I am eager to read the sequel.
November 27, 2012 at 9:36 am
Carolyn J. Rose
Thanks for the nice words about Refuge.
Those platforms were a menace. Fortunately I was in a doorway when I fell off mine, so I had something to hold onto. But several people were in the room and the humiliation factor was high.
November 27, 2012 at 9:34 pm
nancyelauzon
Carolyn, I can totally relate. I’ve had a life-long addiction to shoes, trumped only by my addiction to bags. I’ve gotten smarter about which ones I buy, but I’m afraid there’s no complete cure, if there is I haven’t discovered it yet. Blame it on my Mom, she loved shoes too. Especially Italian leather. You can’t fight your genes!
November 28, 2012 at 11:37 am
Judith Mehl
I’d mentioned earlier that this blog really got my attention because my main character in my series: “Formula for Murder” and “Game, Set, Murder,” has an addiction to shoes. But all the comments have been so enlightening. I can’t wait for my character, Kat, to wear two different shoes, for instance. You folks are wonderful. Thanks.
Judith Mehl
December 2, 2012 at 1:11 pm
Carolyn J. Rose
Thank you all for stopping by. The winner of the drawing is Melissa Robitille.
But I’m always the winner when the Dames let me be a guest on their blog. Hope to be back soon.